Hotel Pontotoc, nestled in the center of Downtown Memphis in the historic South Main district, has a rich tapestry of history that spans over a century. From its inception as a European-style hotel that catered to railway and riverboat travelers to its time as a notable bordello, the property will live its next life as an upscale boutique hotel, restaurant, and bar. The space will also offer an opportunity for individuals and groups to escape into a private green oasis dropped in the heart of a major metropolitan city.
As it prepares to reopen the doors to visitors once again, Hotel Pontotoc is set to become a place where new narratives will unfold, blending its storied past with a restored future.
A tapestry of history
The tale of Hotel Pontotoc began in 1906 when it was built as a European-style hotel. With its proximity to Central Station, it quickly became a favored spot for railway and riverboat travelers. The hotel boasted Turkish baths and originally had 18 bedrooms and nine bathrooms, setting a standard for luxury and comfort.
During the 1920s, under the ownership of E.H. Cash and his wife Elizabeth, Hotel Pontotoc transformed into one of Memphis’ most well-known bordellos. The era was marked by dramatic events, such as the 1928 murder investigation involving regular guests Ora Walkers and Max C. Poindexter, and the mysterious disappearance of actor Thaddus Wilbur, who was last seen at the hotel.
In 1929, the hotel was purchased by Dionysos (Dan) Touliatos. He converted it into a family hotel. The Touliatos family was known for their hospitality, often hosting members of the Greek community and throwing lively parties. The space also became a haven for actors and vaudeville performers from the nearby Orpheum and other local theaters. Notably, the hotel housed Mexican artist Dionicio Rodriguez in the early 1930s while he sculpted the Crystal Shrine Grotto.
The 1970s and 1980s brought change and revival, with the property becoming The Cellar Club nightclub. In the 1980s, Leigh and Terry Davis acquired the hotel, transforming the abandoned nightclub into a recording studio and hosting some of the city’s most legendary Halloween parties.
Somewhere between all those years of change, Elvis is said to have lost his virginity here.
In 2022, partners Tony Kuhn and Joseph Lewis acquired Hotel Pontotoc. With a commitment to preserving its historical essence while infusing modern grandeur, they embarked on a journey to bring the hotel back to its former glory.
A restored legacy
Hotel Pontotoc stands ready to embrace its next chapter. Every corner tells tales elegantly interwoven with contemporary touches that invite guests to write their own stories.
The meticulous restoration captures the timeless elegance and enduring appeal of the hotel’s original design, with an eye for detail that honors its rich heritage. The intimate setting of the 10 rooms, each thoughtfully designed with luxurious amenities, offers a sanctuary for those seeking both comfort and sophistication. As the hotel’s bar, The Dame is set to be a hub where guests can mingle and savor innovative cocktails crafted with the finest ingredients.
While Hotel Pontotoc prepares to reopen its doors, we invite you to be part of its living history. From hosting legendary figures to providing an escape for travelers, Hotel Pontotoc is an icon in Downtown Memphis. Come, be a part of the story, and create memories that will be cherished for generations to come.